Scranton Times Editorial: Olyphant Boro Approval Of $101 Million Data Center Settlement Without Real Public Input Was A Bad Night For The Democratic Process And Appalling

Posted

Monday was a big night for data centers in Northeast Pennsylvania, and a bad one for the democratic process.

We are appalled that five council members in the borough of Olyphant voted during a special meeting to approve the settlement of a lawsuit that will allow the controversial Project Triboro data center campus to be built along a massive swath of borough property just off Marshwood Road and Route 247. 

But let’s be clear about a few things before we delve into the reasons why.

This is not because we don’t realize there is inherent economic value for area communities hosting a modest amount of well-regulated data centers in specifically zoned areas a reasonable distance from homes. 

It is also not because we don’t understand community benefits agreements like the one Olyphant gets with this settlement can ease an awful lot financial burdens on small towns rubbing nickels together to keep employees paid and services running.

It’s because no data center is harmless enough, no financial windfall big enough, to forfeit a citizen’s right to question a developer about potential financial, environmental and health impacts their presence will force upon them.

No aspect of the democratic process should be discarded for a price, and no elected officials should consider forfeiting one because the money is too good.

Yet, when Olyphant council members Tony Delfino, Beth Frushon, Fred Hartman, Eric Hartshorn and President Jimmy Baldan voted both to settle developer ERCOR Triboro LLC’s suit and accept a 15-year, $101 million community benefits agreement in exchange, it meant two things: Development of ERCOR’s data center campus was allowed to proceed, and developers would never have to answer to the community during the conditional use hearing process. 

That is when residents would have been allowed the opportunity, during public hearings, to cross-examine representatives from the data center and present their own evidence either in support of or against the project.

It’s a critical part of the process, and really the best defense residents have against large corporations seeking to buy inexpensive land in small communities to house their businesses. 

That is why we ask state lawmakers to update the Pennsylvania Municipalities Planning Code to mandate that these all-important hearings can’t be canceled by settlements between governing boards and corporate developers.

On Monday, more than two dozen residents spoke out against the settlement, asking those elected officials to either vote against it or consider it further. Hundreds cheered them on. None came to the podium supporting the measure.

The council approved it, 5-2, anyway.

Imagine you want to start a business in your community.

Consider the possibility that, upon application for any permits you might need to proceed, there is a state law requiring you to sit in front of those who live in that community and answer any questions they may have about the impacts your new business will have on their quality of life. 

They can demand to know how much power and water your company will use, how much space it needs, how it will impact parking and traffic, how noisy it will be, whether there will be any long-term environmental impacts to consider.

Now, think about this: If you were running a clean, quiet business you knew would be completely harmless to neighbors, how much money would you pay to avoid that legally required process altogether? A thousand bucks? A hundred?

Would you even pay $10?

Essentially, this is the scenario resident Stephanie Sakson posed to the council. 

And, we believe it’s something all future governmental boards that surely will find themselves in the same situation should consider much more democratically than Olyphant council members did.

As Sakson put it: “A responsible corporate neighbor should welcome transparency.”

That is why we ask ERCOR to do the right thing by the people: Hold the public hearings.

Answer the questions.

Be honest about the impacts.

It matters little in terms of a decision, considering the council accepted the CBA. 

But people have the right to know what long-term risks their corporate neighbors are bringing to the community, even if the Olyphant Borough Council sold that right to ERCOR already.

The least major corporations should be willing to do is be up front with citizens about all of it. The least elected officials should be willing to do is let their constituents have a voice.

Zoning and police powers exist to protect public health and safety based on land-use criteria. 

The least the state can do is ensure those powers for residents are not bartered away behind closed doors.

Resource Links - Olyphant Boro:

-- Scranton Times: Olyphant Boro Council Approves $101 Million A.I. Data Center Settlement Over The Objections Of More Than 200 People At The Meeting Amid Heavy Police Presence

-- Scranton Times: A.I. Data Center Opponents React To Olyphant Boro Council Approval Of $101 Million Community Benefits Settlement: ‘It Doesn’t Get Worse Than That’

-- WVIA: Olyphant Council Sides With A.I. Data Center Developer And $101 Million Settlement Over Pleas From Residents

-- Scranton Times: Lackawanna County Rescinds Tax Abatement On Proposed Olyphant A.I. Data Center Site After Olyphant Boro Council Approved $101 Million Community Benefits Settlement

-- WVIA: Lackawanna County Commissioners Rescind Tax Break For Proposed Olyphant A.I. Data Centers

Related Articles This Week:

-- Utility Dive: PA Consumer Advocate Darryl Lawrence Joins Advocates In 7 Other PJM States, Independent PJM Market Monitor Urging PJM To Delay December Generation Auction To Avoid Billions In Added Costs To Consumers  [PaEN] 

-- Gov. Shapiro: New PJM Governance Rules Ensure The Electric Grid Will Continue To Be Held Captive By ‘Greedy Corporate Interests’  [PaEN]  

-- PUC Updates Comment Schedule On New Tools To Manage Data Centers During Emergency Periods Of Strained Electricity Supplies And Curtailments To Maintain Grid Reliability  [PaEN] 

-- North American Electric Reliability Corp. Winter Outlook: Extreme Winter Weather Conditions May Result In Electricity Supply Shortfalls Due To Data Center Demands, Impacts On Natural Gas Distribution Systems  [PaEN] 

-- Legislators, Environmental Leaders Unveil 100-Day Blueprint To Lower Electricity Bills, Rein In Data Centers, Expand Clean Energy  [PaEN] 

-- Spotlight PA: PA Consumer Advocate Files Complaint Against PPL Electric Aimed At Forcing A.I. Data Centers To Pay Their Fair Share

-- Spotlight PA: Utility Customers Who Shop For Energy Suppliers Pay More; PUC Agrees Numbers Raise Concerns, But Root Cause Of Extra Costs Is Unclear

-- DEP: About 25 Data Center Projects In Some Stage Of Permitting In PA, None Have Signed A Consent Order Saying They Will Comply With GRID Standards Under Governor’s Executive Order  [PaEN] 

-- Marcellus Drilling News: Status Of 27 PA Data Centers In Permitting Process And Their Sources Of Power  [PDF of Article]

-- PA Data Center Ordinance Tracker By County, Municipality, City 

-- PA Capital-Star: Independent PJM Market Monitor Warns Of Another $5 to $10 Billion In Electricity Grid Costs On Consumers By Data Centers After Delayed PJM Market Reforms

-- PUC Pushes To Close Pennsylvania’s Utility Assistance Consumer Assistance Program Gap

NewsClips:

-- PA Capital-Star: Environmentalists Outline Blue-Trifecta Data Center, Energy Priorities In Capitol Rally

-- WESA - Rachel McDevitt: What Democrat Control In Harrisburg Could Mean For PA A.I. Data Centers

-- Spotlight PA/Inside Climate News: A.I. Data Center Outrage Helped Sweep PA Democrats Into Office, What Comes Next? 

-- The Allegheny Front: Will Democrats’ Control Of PA State Government Spur Climate Action In Pennsylvania? 

-- LancasterOnline: As Three Mile Island Nuclear Power Plant Prepares To Restart As Data Center Power Power Plant, Lessons From 1979 Meltdown Remain Relevant  

-- LancasterOnline: PPL Electric Pays $9.9 Million For 143 Acre Farm To Serve As Substation For Lancaster City A.I. Data Center

-- National Fuel Gas: PUC Approves 3.5% Natural Gas Delivery Base Rate Increase

-- WESA: Help With Heating Bills Now Available For Some PA Residents Through Low-Income Home Energy Assistance

-- TribLive: Lifeline For Coal Power Plants: EPA, State Grant Extension To Keystone, Conemaugh Plants In Indiana, Armstrong Counties [Both Plants Hope To Sell Power To Data Centers] 

-- Utility Dive: PPL Increases Capital Spending, Projects 50 GW Load Growth Due To Data Centers; Data Center Restrictions Enacted In Other States Could Push More Projects To Pennsylvania, KY  

-- Utility Dive: PJM Interconnection Proposes 1-Year Process For Speeding Generation Connections

-- PJM: Plan Would Cut Generation, Transmission Service Interconnections For Large Loads To 1 Year

-- PJM: Proposes New Rules To Protect Grid Reliability As A.I. Data Center Demand Grows

-- Pew Research Center: With Surplus PJM Interconnection Service, Ohio And Pennsylvania Could Unlock Gigawatts Of New Energy Generation Quickly, At Low Cost

-- Utility Dive: High Demand For Natural Gas Turbine Generators  Could Persist Thru 2035: Siemens Energy

-- Utility Dive: US DOE Issues Order To Keep Michigan Coal Power Plant Online In Violation Of Federal Court Order

-- TribLive/AP: US Senate Approves Bill To Speed Up Permitting Energy Projects, Force A.I. Data Centers To Pay For Energy Costs

[Posted: November 20, 2026]  PA Environment Digest